Tuesday 01 December 2020

Expat anger mounts as 14,000 sign petition against 30% ruling cut

Photo: Joep Poulssen

Almost 14,000 people have so far signed a petition urging the Dutch government not to make its decision to limit the 30% ruling for international workers retroactive, after the surprise decision was announced last month.

New Facebook groups Screwed Expats and International Professionals against Retroactive Ruling have also launched a fund-raising campaign to raise at least €10,000 to fight the government’s decision, in the courts if necessary.

‘We support the authority of the Dutch government to change their policy towards future expats as they see fit,’ the fund raising page states. ‘However, these changes should not impact current expats already residing here in the Netherlands, who came here based on a promise of eight to 10 years of the 30% ruling. No reneging.’

Last month tax minister Menno Snel said the ruling, which allows some 60,000 expats and Dutch nationals who have been away for more than 10 years to reduce their tax bills, will only be claimable for five years from 2019, and that the change will be applied to people who are already receiving the tax break.

The finance ministry has also confirmed to DutchNews.nl that there will be no period of transition for current claimants.

The change to the regulations, which will be formally announced when the government presents its 2019 spending plans in September, was first mentioned in last year’s coalition agreement. Nevertheless, the decision to cut the entitlement of existing claimants has generated a wave of concern among expats and companies which employ international workers.

European court

Joost van Benthum, a tax lawyer and senior manager at law firm AKD, says he has been contacted by several corporate clients concerned about the implications, particularly the lack of a transition agreement for employees currently benefiting from the 30% ruling.

‘I am sure some people will start legal proceedings in order to obtain confirmation whether the changes are in line with Dutch and European law,’ he told DutchNews.nl.

‘Ministers may well introduce some sort of transition period before the plan is formally presented to parliament during the budget in September. However, there are currently no concrete indications that this is being considered.’

More tax

The change will have considerable financial implications for international staff who are able to claim the ruling, which only benefits expats who meet strict income requirements and lived at least 150 km from a Dutch border before moving here.

According to tax advisor Lennart Suurmond, the change will mean someone earning €60,000 a year will have to pay around €8,000 more a year in tax.

Henk Jansen, of mortgage advisory group Expat Mortgages, said he thinks the change will make the Netherlands less attractive to internationals and that he has been contacted by dozens of clients worried about how they are going to pay for their homes.

‘I think it’s ridiculous to “punish” existing beneficiaries by deducting three years from the eights years they had been led to expect,’ he said.


One expat who has donated money to the fund-raising campaign said on the fundraising website: ‘I arrived in the Netherlands last September. I just bought an apartment here this month. And now the Dutch government is stabbing me in the back by changing the law retroactively when I just took a 30-year mortgage. This is disgusting and dishonest.’

José de Boer, a financial advisor who specialises in helping expats with their financial planning, said she works with people who have based their mortgages and all their financial planning on getting the 30% ruling for eight years.

‘Now the government turns round and says they can only have five years after all,’ she said. ‘This is causing a lot of uncertainty, costing people thousands of euros and damaging the credibility of the government.’

Have you been affected by this ruling or are you an employer with international staff who will be hit. Please get in touch with editor@dutchnews.nl

You can also comment directly on this article in the section below.

Thank you for donating to DutchNews.nl

The DutchNews.nl team would like to thank all the generous readers who have made a donation in recent weeks. Your financial support has helped us to expand our coverage of the coronavirus crisis into the evenings and weekends and make sure you are kept up to date with the latest developments.

DutchNews.nl has been free for 14 years, but without the financial backing of our readers, we would not be able to provide you with fair and accurate news and features about all things Dutch. Your contributions make this possible.

If you have not yet made a donation, but would like to, you can do so via Ideal, credit card or Paypal.